Rebellions of 1837 justified or not

The three most important of these were: The Upper Canada Rebellion also ended quite unsuccessful. Jobs The Rebellions of - The rebellions in Lower Canada that took place in were aimed at gaining greater independence from Great Britain.

Seeing that defeat was inevitable, Nelson fled the scene for the US and, with this; the Patriots Rebellion came to an end. Finding the place deserted, British soldiers and Iroquois warriors proceeded to pillage and plunder. Rebellion in Upper Canada and Lower Canada also broke out after the Legislative Assembly elections were corrupted.

In 1837, were the Canadian rebels justified in taking up arms against the official government?

Investigators have traditionally failed to take on an insider's perspective of the Rebellions as they were lived and assessed by the Iroquois. The second battle, at Saint-Charles-sur-Richelieu, resulted in a crushing defeat for the Patriots.

The Rebellions Of Upper And Lower Canada

Though the number killed on each side was equal, the strength and tenacity of the Patriot forces shook the British, and they retreated from the battlefield.

These relationships did indeed shape Kahnawake's intervention. The rebels believed that the right of citizens to participate in the political process through the election of representatives was the most important right, and they sought to make the legislative council elective rather than appointed.

Getting in deeper into the main causes of the rebellion, there was a big problem the people had with the government systems.

The Significance Of the Rebellion of 1837 – Essay.

This time the repression was even fiercer: Studies have suggested that despite the common presence of divisive tendencies within Native American communities, whose sense of collective identity can prevail in the face of an external threat to resources, land, and identity.

Another view is that the insurgencies amounted to pointless bloodletting, which may have even slowed the pace of reform. As the situation in Lower Canada approached crisis the British concentrated their troops there, making it apparent that they planned on using armed force against the Patriots.

Mackenzie in Upper Canada. In his opinion, it was necessary to give the elected assembly more power. As a response, they must face inertia to this change. He quickly became a folk hero among the common man in Upper Canada who generally felt that he was right about the family compact and that something should be done.

Although this account is often dismissed by non-Native historians, there are some sources that indicate that Kahnawake resident Marie Kawananoron did indeed see the Patriotes at the outskirts of the village. In May of he decide that he could run a newspaper and started the Colonial Advocate, in Queenstown, which was a newspaper which served as an opposition position to the group known as the family compact who were firmly in power in Upper Canada.

Responsible Government Those people who believed in republicanism also believed that government should be accountable to the people and not the king. Some group has to demand change.

The report stated that the conflict was between two races or nations of people living in a single state. Further, when attempts have been made to explore the underlying causes of Kahnawake's involvement, interpretive research has been quite limited. He proposed that the Governor choose his advisers — in effect, his cabinet — from among men who enjoyed the confidence of the Assembly.

By December of his high opinion of the American Republic was leading him to believe that the American Revolution might be the only practical example of how change might be effected in Upper Canada.

Some of these factors are heavily detailed in the letters of, Joseph Marcouxthe secular priest residing in Kahnawake during the time of the Rebellions. To solve the problem, Durham proposed to unite Upper and Lower Canada, as the English party had previously suggested.

Many were jailed, others sent to the penal colony in Australia, and seventeen were hung for their role in the uprising. Why or why not. These farmers barely survived widespread crop failures in —37, and now faced lawsuits from merchants trying to collect old debts.

The Province of Canada came into being inand this in turn led to the introduction of responsible government. This ideology was based on equal rights of each individual.

The best way to accomplish this assimilation would be to unite Upper Canada and Lower Canada into a single colony, allow for an elected assembly, and encourage a policy of British and Irish immigration to Canada.

Lower Canada Rebellion

On December 6, Mackenzie had gathered a group of reformers who were worked into frenzy and decided to march on Toronto. For instance, at the time, the Indian Department was seeking ways to reduce its expenses by curtailing annuities it had been providing to Native people.

Of course this was only a report though. On December 7th the government forces had recovered and were organized enough to mount an expedition to the Tavern where they easily routed Mackenzie and his men. Cause and Effect: The Canadian Rebellions of and Words | 7 Pages.

The research in this proposal primarily focuses on the rebellions that took place in both upper and Lower Canada during From looking at it from the rebels point of view, they felt justified in taking up arms against the official government. In both the Upper and Lower Rebellions ofrebel forces felt that the.

The Lower Canada Rebellion (French: La rébellion du Bas-Canada), commonly referred to as the Patriots' War (French: La Guerre des patriotes) by Quebecers, is the name given to the armed conflict in –38 between the rebels of Lower Canada (now Quebec) and the British colonial power of that province.

The Rebellions Of Upper And Lower Canada Essay - Part 2

Nov 20,  · Is Armed Rebellion Ever Justifiable? 10 POINTS Easy? By comparison, the upper and lower Canadian rebellions of / 38 were minor uprisings. Perhaps the biggest difference is that though the small group of radicals who started these rebellions were against various policies of the English, they did not have the grand Status: Resolved.

Rebellion in Canada, – Autocracy, Rebellion and Liberty (Volume 1) (() excerpt volume 1; Rebellion in Canada, –, Volume 2: The Irish, the Fenians and the Metis () excerpt for volume 2; Ducharme, Michel ().

Kahnawake Iroquois and the Rebellions of 1837–38

"Closing the Last Chapter of the Atlantic Revolution: The –38 Rebellions in Upper and Lower. From looking at it from the rebels point of view, they felt justified in taking up arms against the official government.

In both the Upper and Lower Rebellions ofrebel forces felt that the official governments were not being responsive to their needs.

Rebellions of 1837 justified or not
Rated 5/5 based on 83 review
The Rebellions of - Ms. Ledoux's Class: